 |
|
Freelance art writer Justo Sanchez involved the
Florida Attorney General’s Office to get records
from the Bass Museum. |
Gary Farmer, the cultural affairs
program manager for the city of Miami Beach, took over the
helm of the Bass Museum last week. As interim director,
Farmer will help the museum’s board of trustees choose a
search firm to find a permanent replacement for outgoing
Director Diane Camber.
After 26 years as director of the Bass Museum, Camber’s
retirement comes as the museum finds itself forced by its
accrediting body to answer questions of impropriety
surrounding its recent exhibit The Private Jade
Collection of Her Imperial Highness Princess Thi-Nga of
Vietnam, which ran from Feb. 8 through April 29. The
Bass also has been forced to open its records and board
meetings to the public, a transparency they apparently have
been reluctant to allow in the past. Camber’s last day was
June 29.
Farmer was introduced to members of the Friends of the Bass
Board at their June 28 meeting. He will temporarily oversee
the museum’s operations while still being responsible for
his job at City Hall. He moved into Camber’s office at the
Bass on July 2.
“I’m
totally devoted to the cultural scene in Miami Beach,”
Farmer told the Friends, while surrounded by Asian art in
the museum’s Room 115.
Farmer said his main goal while at the Bass is to quickly
find a suitable permanent director. Symbolic of his
temporary role, Farmer said he wants to be called interim
administrator, as opposed to interim director. His first
priority is to find search firms, one of which will be
chosen by the Bass Board of Trustees, to find Camber’s
permanent replacement. The search process itself is expected
to take four to six months. Farmer hopes to present the
trustees with a list of search firms at a meeting to be held
sometime this month. A single search firm will eventually be
hired, tasked with advertising nationally, performing
background checks and conducting initial interviews to
compile a list of finalists for a special committee.
Farmer said he doesn’t know how much the Bass is willing to
pay its next director. Camber was earning $134,063 per year.
One
topic that was on the June 28 agenda of the Friends of the
Bass meeting was how Sunshine Law pertains to the Friends
board members, as well as trustees. It was to be presented
by the city of Miami Beach, but had to be postponed because
of a scheduling conflict. Deputy City Attorney Jean Olin
told the SunPost the city will give a presentation of
Sunshine Law to board members at the Bass’ July trustees
meeting. As of press time, the museum had yet to schedule
that meeting.
Why
the sudden interest in Sunshine Law? It was recently opined
that because the Bass Museum receives public funding, its
trustees and Friends must abide by the Sunshine rules, Miami
Beach City Attorney Jose Smith told the SunPost.
The
total 2007 budget for the Bass is about $2.7 million,
according to Farmer. The Friends of the Bass supply about
$1.2 million of that through government grants, private
support and earned income from admissions, the museum shop
and renting out the museum for special events, he said. The
taxpayers of the city of Miami Beach supply the other
approximately $1.5 million.
To
comply with Sunshine Law, all Bass Museum board meetings
must be advertised and open to the public, and all related
documentation is public record. Just like with city
commissioners, board members can only discuss Bass business
in public. Mary Heaton, the Bass’ executive assistant, told
the SunPost that from now on trustee and Friends
meetings will be advertised on the city of Miami Beach Web
site and in the Miami Herald, something not usually
done in the past.
Farmer, who after only a little more than a week in the
museum is still trying to learn how the place ran under
Camber, said he doesn’t believe the Friends were
intentionally acting outside the Sunshine.
“Because the Friends of the Bass have been using museum
staff, they do have to come into the Sunshine,” Farmer said.
“If they were acting with their own staff like most Friends
[type] groups, they wouldn’t have to act in the Sunshine.”
Farmer said he believes the Friends will eventually choose
to stop using museum staff, something he sees as necessary
to be an effective fundraising organization. He theorized
that being forced to reveal the names of all the private
citizens the museum solicits for money will hurt fundraising
efforts. But for now he doesn’t believe there is enough
money to justify the Friends having its own staff, said
Farmer. The trustees’ meetings, he said, will always have to
be noticed.
Though no one would confirm it on the record, City Attorney
Smith said he assumed the sudden interest in Sunshine Law at
the Bass was sparked by media attention on questionable
ethics surrounding The Princess Jade Collection.
Justo Sanchez, a local freelance journalist and art
historian, investigated the collection for more than four
months before filing a list of complaints to the American
Association of Museums (AAM), of which the Bass is an
accredited member. He was forced to involve both the Florida
Attorney General and the City Attorney’s Office to get board
minutes from the Bass related to the approval of the Jade
Collection exhibit.
In
late March, Sanchez received a written response from Camber
to a public records request he’d made. She informed him that
Bass board meeting minutes were not public record. Sanchez
contacted Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum’s office
for assistance. In early April, representatives from
McCollum’s office mediated on Sanchez’s behalf.
“We
sent a letter to the executive director [Camber] and asked
if the museum wanted to participate in our public records
mediation program,” spokesperson for the Florida Attorney
General Sandi Copes told the SunPost. Camber opted
not to participate and instead gave Sanchez the documents
he’d requested.
Sanchez maintains that showing the collection created
conflicts of interest because of Princess Thi-Nga’s
governing influence over the museum. Besides her role as
president of the Friends of the Bass Museum, she is the
chairperson of the Bass’ Board of Trustees. Sanchez also
questions the provenance of the collection, and goes so far
as to claim Thi-Nga’s title of princess is a fraud. The
SunPost broke the story of Sanchez and the AAM’s
examination of the Bass in a June 21 feature titled:
“Accreditation at Risk.”
Despite all the current focus on transparency, one staff
member still attempted to hold back public records from the
SunPost. On June 29 the SunPost sent an e-mail
request to Lee Ortega, director of marketing and public
relations at the Bass, for a copy of the Bass’ response to
the AAM’s examination of the museum.
Later that same day Ortega replied, “Correspondence between
the Bass Museum and American Association of Museums is not
public information.”
The
City Attorney’s Office, however, quickly intervened on the
newspaper’s behalf.
When
the SunPost forwarded Ortega’s reply to Deputy City
Attorney Olin, she responded within minutes. “The document
you requested is a public record,” wrote Olin. “I just spoke
with Max Sklar and he will e-mail you a copy of the Bass’
response immediately.”
Sklar is the director of tourism and cultural
development for the city of Miami Beach. Within an hour of
Olin’s e-mail, he e-mailed the SunPost everything it
had requested, including a letter attributed to Camber that
attempts to address the AAM inquiry. A portion of the letter
refers to improper record-keeping relating to discussions of
the Jade Collection exhibit.
“In
retrospect, the Director/Chief Curator misjudged the
situation and now realizes she should have ensured that
there was a record of all discussion of this exhibition,”
wrote Camber, referring to herself.
Now
it’s up to the AAM to judge whether or not the Bass Museum
broke any internal rules or standards regarding its
accreditation.
Jason Hall, director of government and media relations at
the AAM, told the SunPost he could not comment on
whether the Bass’ response had been received. He also could
not give a time frame, other than as quickly as possible, as
to when the AAM would make a determination on the complaint.
If the AAM does determine the Bass broke any rules of
accreditation, there are many actions it could take.
“There are a range of things, from, for example, suggesting
the museum correct x, to the very most serious of
cases of pulling their accreditation,” Hall said.
Comments?
E-mail
ben@miamisunpost.com.