|
Party Poopers
Arrests,
Noise Violations, Bankruptcy: Miami's Only Nonstop Nightlife
District Is Taking a Sound Beating
By Rebecca
Wakefield
 |
|
Is
the city of Miami ready to dump its entertainment
district? Photo by Jacqueline Carini/jacqueline.nexsoftware.com |
“I think you can finally see the light at
the end of the tunnel,” Miami Mayor Manny Diaz said in a recent
Miami Herald article about business investment in the
city’s decidedly dilapidated downtown. “At least we’re talking
about a transition. Not too many years ago, there was zero
happening downtown. Now, we’re seeing a lot happening. Downtown
is becoming a desirable place to live, work and shop.”
Notice
he didn’t say “and party till the break of dawn.”
These
are tougher times for clubs in downtown Miami. A new day finds
them stumbling blearily into the sunlight to discover that the
alleged desirability factor they helped create is now rapidly
reducing their cachet — at least as the city sees it.
In
March, one megaclub’s owner and his general manager were
unceremoniously arrested in the street for a noise violation. In
June, another monster club got shut down through a combination
of its own noisy hubris and a failure to pay bills. Even tony
restaurant lounge Karu and Y had a run-in with the shushing
brigade. Hard to believe it would come to this just a few years
after the city of Miami created its first entertainment
district, complete with 24-hour liquor licenses, along a
desolate stretch of Northeast 11th Street.
If
there’s anyone to thank (or curse, depending on perspective) for
this turn of events, it is George “Not Missing” Link, a resident
and assistant head of security of Park Place by the Bay, a
30-story apartment building located at 915 NW First Ave.,
an unfortunate two blocks from Club Space. Link is a character
by anyone’s standard, a transplant from Manhattan who has made
it his special mission to agitate public officials on behalf of
fellow residents beleaguered by club row.
“[The clubs] draws to the area the worst element around,”
Link explained in his thick New York accent. “It’s not just
the noise. It’s the drugs, the DUIs, people walking around
peeing and puking in the streets. I don't care how
professional you are, or if you drive a BMW. When you’re
shit-faced, you’re ugly.”
He
added: “I’m not in the thing to close the clubs. I’m trying
to get rid of, how can I say, unbecoming persons.” And by
this, he also means club owners who won’t turn down the
noise.
To
this end, Link has written to nearly every level of
government save the president. He faxed the governor, the
mayor and the police chief, among others. For the most part,
it did no good. Then he found an ally at the Venetia,
located all the way up on 15th Street and across Biscayne
Boulevard, beyond I-395 and the Carnival Center, where
state-of-the-art sound systems still pumped into their
bedroom windows.
Stacey Stokes, a 12-year resident and current vice president
of the Venetia’s condo association, described the sensation
as a year’s worth of “torture.” It was worse for residents
on the highest levels of the building, where the sound waves
were more intense. “I love to have my coffee on the terrace
Sunday mornings,” she said. “It's like having a headache to
hear that pounding.”
After feedback from other residents (even some at the Grand,
a block north, complained), Stokes also made the rounds of
public officials. For ammunition, she went to the police
department and asked for all the noise complaints for 11th
Street. She says she was told it would cost “something like
$200” to get a printout of six months of complaints. If
true, that’s clearly outrageous.
So
Stokes drew up a petition and went over to Park Place to see
if they would help her fight the noise. Link personally
knocked on doors and garnered some 500 signatures. Stokes
also got in touch with Commissioner Marc Sarnoff, who
immediately put the heavy foot on city officials to do
something.
But
you know how government is. There are many different people
interpreting an order and filtering that through whatever
agenda they may have. Thus mistakes are made.
That
was how Club Space owner Louis Puig ended up getting
arrested on March 18 during the Winter Music Conference,
along with Club Space’s general manager Markus Westreicher.
One of Puig’s lawyers, former state prosecutor Alex Fox,
described the situation as “an outrageous violation” of
Puig’s and Westreicher’s rights, i.e., typical Miami cop
overreaction to a situation that could have been handled in
a much better way. “They arrested two guys for nothing and
they sat in jail for eight to 10 hours,” he told me.
The
arrest (as first reported by the SunPost’s
debaucherous 411 celebrity columnist, Kris Conesa) caused
quite a stir in clubland, with critics of the bombastic Puig
cheering and fans of Club Space worrying that this
represented the opening salvo of a “quality of life” war
many had predicted once the condos started to rise in
downtown. This sort of thing is old news on South Beach, but
the clubs across the bay have enjoyed relatively free reign
for several years.
Dan
Vidal, operations manager/photo editor for nightlife Web
site cooljunkie.com, posted a story about the arrest hours
after it happened. He wrote that Nocturnal as well as Space
had their outdoor sound systems shut down for noise
complaints that night, and that possibly a couple of
managers for the nearby Area 51/Allure/Adrenaline complex
were arrested. Vidal is one of the more articulate denizens
of nightlife and a veteran photographer of the scene. So I
asked him: Does the city’s newfound interest in overgrown
stereo systems bode ill for the future of nightlife in
downtown Miami?
“The
way things are going, what it really comes down to is that
the condos are going to make life difficult for
entertainment-oriented businesses in the area,” Vidal
opined. “Noise violations will be the cover story, but
realistically what it is going to be coming down to is that
the condo-dwellers aren’t going to want ‘those people’ in
the area once all the condos are done. Simply put, clubs
like Space, Pawn Shop, Discotekka, etc., tend to cater to
markets that aren’t the upscale VIP sort. Whereas the condo
residents, if they go out to clubs at all, tend to go to
[upscale] venues. ... So what I’m seeing here in the
future is a microcosm of a class war.”
One
reason the Club Space incident sent shock waves through
clubland is that it is sort of the godfather club of the
area. Open since 2000, Club Space has survived a move down
the street, closing/opening parties, name changes, Puig’s
various turf battles with other venues and promoters,
lawsuits from patrons charging they were beaten up by
bouncers, and a major drug bust in 2003, which netted nearly
a dozen clubgoers and a couple of employees.
But
Space is still popular with the dance crowd, most of whom
are relatively harmless.
I've
heard rumors that the Puig arrest on March 18 was in part
motivated by a personal beef between Club Space and a police
commander, but Puig wouldn’t return my phone or e-mail
messages, and the commander in question recently retired, so
who knows. But several people who either were present at the
scene, or are close to Puig, told me the arrest wasn’t
exactly textbook.
One
source was Miami Police Officer Geovani Nunez, who was
working off-duty security outside Club Space at the time of
the arrest. Nunez told me he was working that night along
with two other officers outside the club, mostly directing
traffic. Other off-duty officers were stationed outside
other clubs up and down the street. All was well until about
2:45 a.m., when Nunez noticed that Lt. Windsor Lozano was in
the street, talking with Space GM Westreicher. Shortly, Puig
showed up and the three conversed.
Nunez said another superior, Lt. Bernard Johnson, walked
over from his post at Nocturnal and gestured at the officers
in front of Space to converge on Puig and Westreicher. Nunez
said Johnson directed him to pat the two men down. Nunez
complied but wondered why it was necessary since these were
hardly seasoned criminals. He couldn’t figure out why they
were being arrested. Then he went back to directing traffic.
“A few minutes later, Lt. Johnson calls me over there,”
Nunez related. “His words to me are, ‘Your loyalty lies with
the city of Miami. I don’t care if you disagree with the
arrest. It’s a good arrest.’”
Nunez said that later another officer patted down and
searched both men again. Puig started taking off his jewelry
in preparation for going to jail. “I’m watching this,
everyone on the scene were all dazed and confused as to what
they were going to charge them with,” Nunez recalled. “The
[law enforcement statute] book is open in the trunk of
Officer Simmons’ car and they are scanning page by page.
That right there told me they didn’t know what they’re
doing.”
Nunez said the higher-ranking officers had Simmons make the
arrest and fill out the form, even though she was not the
one to witness the noise violation. There is a note to that
effect on the arrest form itself. Nunez said he didn’t see
any noise meters being used and none of the officers that
night received a noise complaint as far as he knew. “In my
opinion, they’ve been wanting that club for a long time,” he
said. “Downtown has always been a quiet area. The clubs
changed that. Space is the godfather of the clubs. Louis
Puig is the Sam Walton, the Walt Disney of the club
industry.”
While you digest that nugget of wisdom, let me just add that
on Monday Puig’s attorney Alex Fox told me that he’d been
notified the state was dropping the charges against both
men, moved in part by Nunez’s story. As of press time, the
county clerk’s record didn’t reflect that, but these things
take time. As for Nunez, he mentioned that he was punished
by his department for questioning the arrest, but did not
want to go into details. I asked him why he talked to me.
“I’m tired of the silence,” he replied. “They can stick that
blue line up their ass.”
Adding to the unease in clubland, on May 22 local DJ Danny
Tenaglia posted an anguished message on burlingtonnights.com
about the closing of Twilo, a New York club legend that had
opened its doors in downtown Miami less than a year ago.
Tenaglia, who opened Space seven years ago, was a regular DJ
at Twilo. “TWILO MIAMI is NO MORE!” he wrote. “SO SAD TO SAY
THIS PEOPLE. BUT THERE TRULY WAS NO HOPE. 11th Street in
Miami has become: THE MOST GHETTO OF CLUBLANDS - THAT MY
EYES HAS EVER WITNESSED! AND THIS TRULY SADDENS ME DEEPLY!”
Paper Magazine picked up on Tenaglia’s post on June 7
and compared Miami’s club district issues with those
happening on West 27th Street in New York. “The cities’
original concept of keeping all the clubs in one zoned area
has backfired by also bringing all the attendant problems to
one neighborhood — and then blaming the clubs,” the magazine
noted.
On
June 8, two-year-old megaclub Nocturnal was shut down by
Miami Police mid-event. They were executing a judgment lien
against the club’s owner, Glenn Kofman. The lien was the
result of a lawsuit filed by event company Toast of New
York, which had been hired to produce the grand opening of
the nightclub more than two years ago. The company was
supposed to be paid some $300,000.
Kofman’s checks bounced, a lawsuit was filed and Toast of
New York was awarded $1,060,006.80, plus interest. Kofman
still didn’t pay up, so the company brought in the cops to
seize club assets. Lawyers interceded and bought Nocturnal
time, but gave up the club’s liquor license. Two weeks
later, the police shut down the club after it continued to
serve alcohol without the license. Sources indicated to the
SunPost’s Conesa that Nocturnal figured Space had
tipped the cops and caused the raid.
On
the positive side, Club Space has now erected barriers on
its patio to muffle sounds. Nocturnal will do the same if it
ever reopens. Karu & Y on Northwest 14th Street has also
dampened its sonic impact.
Eddie Padilla-Morales, administrator of the downtown NET
office for the city of Miami, called recent events evidence
of the “natural progression” of the area. “When the
[entertainment] district was created, there was a sense that
at a certain point in time it would become more difficult to
conduct [club] business in the same way,” he said. “That
time has probably come sooner than expected. The trouble is
with the outdoor venues. That will be more difficult with
condos coming on line.”
Padilla-Morales explained that the impact of sound downtown
varies a lot depending on the environment — humidity, wind
direction, ambient noise. The effects of the other human
problems that concentrate in any nightclub district, he
feels, are being mitigated by clubs that are now paying more
attention to the types of promoters and security they have
at their venues.
He
thinks that not only can clubs coexist with condos, but
downtown will require that synergy to revitalize.
Commissioner Sarnoff also believes there’s a place for the
clubs — if the city provides the adult supervision. “They
just need to behave themselves,” he said. “They need to
respect their neighbors.”
Comments?
E-mail
wakefield@miamisunpost.com |