 |
|
Joe Garcia at the Barack Obama event
last week. Photo by Larry Thorson |
Joe Garcia’s ego is like his hair —
wild, unruly and probably in need of some clipping.
But he’s
also very bright and prone to impolitic statements, which
makes for stimulating conversation. Garcia is the director
of the New Democratic Network’s Hispanic Strategy Center and
chairman of the Democratic Party of Miami-Dade County.
Not so long
ago, he was the new face of the Cuban American National
Foundation, once the powerful vehicle of Miami’s most famous
unelected politician — Jorge Mas Canosa. Garcia became
CANF’s executive director toward the end of the Elian
Gonzalez affair, just as the organization, under Chairman
Jorge Mas Santos, began to take a new direction.
Under
Garcia and Mas Santos, CANF became, depending whom you talk
to, either more modern and centrist, or too weak-kneed and
liberal for the tastes of some of its former members, the
leaders of which led an exodus featuring lots of bitter
radio diatribes. Garcia left his position in 2004 to join
the New Democratic Network, which is attempting to revive
the Democratic Party’s decidedly lackluster ground game.
He also won
control of the local Democratic Party, where he’s testing
out some of this strategy business in the apathetic heart of
our sprawling metropolis. Last week he helped orchestrate an
appearance by presidential candidate Barack Obama at the
Miami-Dade County Auditorium. Obama spoke in part about his
support for lifting restrictive bans on Cuban-Americans
visiting family members in Cuba, or sending them money.
Garcia is
also working to get more Democrats elected locally, citing
the recent election of Democrat Luis Garcia to the state
Legislature from a solidly Republican district as a measure
of success. He’s also hounding Raul Martinez, the former
Hialeah mayor, to run against Rep. Lincoln Diaz-Balart.
Garcia and
I had breakfast at the Van Dyke on Lincoln Road recently.
Fresh from the gym, Garcia picked at some concoction of
granola and fruit while he talked my ear off in
characteristic fashion. Here is some of that conversation.
How do you
think CANF is doing without you, Joe? There are those who
feel it is not as relevant an organization as it once was.
CANF is
still the single most important Cuban organization there is.
One of the large problems I had as executive director was
trying to work with other people. Any press conference I
showed up at, I was the center of attention because you’re
the gorilla that’s been in 30 battles and people want to
talk to you. Of course it created jealousy. So CANF has
always had that problem. But it’s leading on the issues. The
position Obama just took on travel restrictions? CANF took
that position last year.
You don’t
think CANF has lost a certain zing in the years since it was
the Mas Canosa cult of personality?
Jorge [Mas
Santos] is doing a good job. Is he his father? No. When the
chairmanship came up, I told Jorge, get as far away from
that as you can and he said, “If I don’t step up, the people
who are running it will destroy it” with this right-wing
crazy stuff and he was right. He brought me in to clean it
up. Some of the people that left were the ones who asked me
to do the job. Look, if someone leaving pulls a sign off the
wall that says “right-wing intransigent” and says, “I’m
the real right-wing intransigent,” I’ll hand them the nail
and hammer so they can put it up at their place.
I know they
criticize the foundation on a regular basis. That’s fine.
They’re playing their Mickey Mouse role. Which is necessary
by the way. One organization can’t carry the left, right and
center at the same time.
OK, so
seven years after Elian, we now have another case of an
international child custody battle. Why isn’t this case
producing the same impact?
I think the
rhetoric is controlled. People understand the mistakes we
made in Elian. Look at the coverage of Obama coming to speak
here. I had 25 people protesting for free outside and inside
I had 1,800 people who paid to be there and at least half of
them were Cuban-Americans. In the heart of little Havana. I
think that was great and it couldn’t have happened a few
years ago.
I agree
with that. I’ve seen the polls showing there are significant
gaps in opinions among Cuban-Americans in Miami depending on
when they got here — the ’60s, the ’80s or the ’90s — on
various Cuba issues. Yet the majority of Cuban-Americans who
actually vote are still holding those traditional views
they’ve held for decades. What do you as the DNC’s man in
Miami, do with that?
Lincoln
Diaz-Balart and Ileana [Ros-Lehtinen] will do TV and say,
“Well the new people don’t vote.” So they don’t matter. It’s
like, “You stupid fuck, sooner or later, they’re going
to vote and they’re going to remember you saying that.”
That’s what makes Bob Graham a statesman. He supported
Haitian issues before Haitians were voting. These people
are registering to vote.
I think
it’s funny that the New Democrat Network’s “Hispanic
strategy” is being represented by a Cuban-American because
the Cuban story is so different than that of any other
Hispanic immigrant group. It’s almost like the Anglo
perspective in other cities. So how do you develop a
strategy across those perspectives?
It is an
Anglo perspective because Cubans hold power in Miami. But
maybe it’s not different. The myth of the
Cuban-American story, yes. Cuban-Americans are supposed to
be these right-wing, self-reliant, bootstrap guys. No other
immigrant group in the history of the United States has
received more aid from the federal government than
Cuban-Americans. And that’s why it’s an immigration success
story. In the end we [Hispanic immigrants] are the same, and
this is probably heresy in the Cuban community.
Immigrants
comprise some of the best characteristics of the
entrepreneurial spirit.
Absolutely.
Another
thing that is different is the exile versus the immigrant
mentality. The exile was thrown out, but they never analyze
why the fuck HE was able to throw them out. An immigrant
says, “This place failed me.” That implies that where I’m
going is better than where I left. Where the exile thinks
that where they left is still somehow better than where they
are. There’s no self-analysis because those points of
reference are different. Castro fucked us, but Cuban culture
is perfectly fine. It’s bullshit. But it’s bullshit and myth
that works. It’s the same way it works for Jews.
Or
Americans for that matter. We believe those myths about
ourselves, which is why it’s so hard to steer clear of
morasses like Vietnam and Iraq.
It’s the
strength of any enclave standing together. The problem for
Cubans in Miami is that we haven’t learned that the things
you can say as a minority you can’t get away with as a
majority. The hyperbole can be offensive. You now have the
responsibility of being the majority.
And the
other thing is learning to accept divisions within the
enclave.
More than
70 percent of Cubans alive today were born under the Castro
government. Fidel Castro, for most people there, is like the
sun, the moon, the tides. He’s like a boulder in the middle
of a field. Cubans in Cuba don’t argue about Fidel Castro —
they plow around him. Cuban-Americans engage in argument
because Castro is not a practical consideration for them.
It’s because the rhetoric became more important than the
reality. It’s a rhetorical game for the first generation [of
Cuban immigrants], but it’s not a rhetorical game if my
daughter is in Cuba.
We have in
Miami significant populations of Colombians, Nicaraguans,
Dominicans, every country in the Americas. Why don’t we see
them in local politics? You would think these groups would
be ripe for Democratic recruitment. Why are you guys so bad
at that?
In the end
the reason democracy works is the alternative has to be
unbearable. This was once the Deep South and the Democratic
Party was this amalgamation that was weird here. They didn’t
need to let the Cubans in. You need one generation, about 20
years, to go from immigration to voting; for the Cubans that
coincided with Ronald Reagan talking about Cuba and the Cold
War. I think in the next election you will see Nicaraguans
vote in huge numbers for Democrats because they’ve seen the
alternative with the Bush administration.
So how do
you engage people in Miami? The voting turnout here is
abysmal.
You’ve
gotta find issues that are important to people and you’ve
got to talk about them. I’m on TV a lot. I don’t let the
space be taken. Because what the Republicans do is they put
up a really good-looking guy in a suit. So the Democrats
have the guy in the tie-dyed shirt who’s got a beard and a
ponytail and lives in a van down by the river and he likes
to smoke pot. And he speaks his opinion and it’s not the
Democratic position. My job is to get rid of that guy. Last
year we decided to go after a Republican state seat in the
heart of Little Havana. [Former Miami Beach Commissioner]
Luis Garcia is a great candidate. He’s old-line Cuban but a
lifelong union member and his son is gay. We pushed out all
the other Democrats, we stopped the internecine wars and we
kicked [Republican] ass. We did it by having a credible
candidate. And we’re busily courting Raul Martinez to run
against Lincoln Diaz-Balart. I’ve seen polling that Raul
would kick Lincoln’s ass.
Please God,
let Raul say yes. We haven’t had a really good boxing match
here in ages.
An outsider
could not have come in and taken over the local Democratic
Party if it wasn’t in such bad shape. One strength we have
is that the modern paradigm of information exchange is more
like the Democratic Party than the Republican Party.
Communication is not hierarchal; it is diffuse. Ideas come
at you from all over the place. That’s good for Democrats
because we’re just not good at the discipline thing. But
then the discipline thing hasn’t worked too well for America
either.
Comments? E-mail wakefield@miamisunpost.com.