|
 |
|
Russell Crowe
takes aim in 3:10 to Yuma, 2007. |
The film 3:10 to Yuma is an
actors’ showcase set in the Old West, which never is a
recipe for box office success, though it can lead to good
cinema. Too bad it doesn’t. The film, directed by James
Mangold (Walk the Line), is a flat, not-involving
bore that flutters during supposed dramatic high points and
ends in a way that will have Western purists crying
blasphemy.
Christian Bale
plays Dan Evans, a weak-willed family man and Civil War
veteran who is facing foreclosure on his home and losing the
respect of his wife (Gretchen Mol) and his oldest son (Logan
Lerman, an emerging talent).
After Ben Wade
(Russell Crowe) and his gang rob a nearby stagecoach, Wade
gallivants with a local barmaid (Vinessa Shaw) and is
captured by a group of men. Soon after, railroad
representative Grayson Butterfield (Dallas Roberts), who is
tired of getting robbed, offers a group of volunteers $200
to help transport Wade to the city of Contention and put him
on the 3:10 train to Yuma — and prison.
Evans, a
crusty old cowboy (Peter Fonda), a veterinarian (Alan Tudyk)
and others accept the offer. Wade warns that his men will
come after him and, sure enough, his pal Charlie Prince (Ben
Foster) does just that.
Bale offers
the same coy, embattled innocence that he successfully
employed as Bruce Wayne in Batman Begins, but adds an
Old West code of honor that forces him to be brave in the
face of imminent danger. Dan Evans clearly is not a
courageous man, and watching Bale buck up the strength to
face a grave standoff is a study in somber and effective
acting. Crowe has more fun, as his character is cunning and
devious with a likable charm.
Unfortunately,
the movie has nothing more to offer. Based on an Elmore
Leonard short story and the 1957 Western starring Glenn Ford
as Wade and Van Heflin as Evans, Mangold’s version never
flashes with the vitality or tension needed to make it
resonate with viewers. It lacks urgency: The two-hour
rendering doesn’t build drama as much as it plods along with
an occasional action sequence thrown in to keep our
attention. We want to be worried for Evans, wonder about
Wade and wait in white-knuckle suspense as the story rises
to a climax. But the journey is so drawn-out that your mind
wanders and starts thinking about the new Batman
movie Bale currently is shooting and the upcoming film
American Gangster with Crowe and Denzel Washington.
After the
success of Walk the Line, Mangold had the power to
choose his next project, and no one can blame him for
remaking one of his personal favorites. The fact that this
often is a bad idea (for evidence, watch Gus Van Sant’s 1998
remake of Psycho, the first movie he made after
Good Will Hunting) seems to have eluded Mangold and,
ironically, he made a movie that lacks the spirit and energy
that originally inspired him.
|
3:10
to Yuma **
Directed by James Mangold. Starring Christian Bale,
Russell Crowe, Gretchen Mol and Peter Fonda.
**** A
genuine must-see
***
Entertaining
**
Mediocre, but not worthless
* A wretched waste of time
Opening in Miami-Dade County this Friday: 3:10 to
Yuma, Shoot ‘Em Up, The Brothers Solomon |