|
Photo
illustration: gettyimages.com.

“With a county
population of 2.6 million people, [experts estimate] we should have
about 600 available beds total. We have 113. … We can fill that in a
weekday,” said Norma Rodriguez of the Women’s Shelter of Hope. “We
see two or three families on a weekend.”
Miami-Dade
County runs two domestic violence shelters. Two others, The Lodge, a
privately run shelter, and the nonprofit Women’s Shelter of Hope,
are not operated by the county although funding filters to them
through the county. The source of funding for all the shelters comes
from the food and beverage taxes we all pay every time we have a
meal out. The money then makes its way through the Domestic Violence
Oversight Board and is finally allocated to the shelters.
Fortunately at
Safe Space North, the hurricanes that ravaged South Florida last
year downed only a few trees. Two other shelters were not so lucky.
Safe Space South in South Miami-Dade was forced to cut its number of
available beds almost in half due to damage from Katrina, and in the
wake of Hurricane Wilma, the Women’s Shelter of Hope was forced to
close completely. According to Rodriguez, the Women’s Shelter of
Hope, the system has lost about 100 beds countywide.
Rodriguez’s
shelter serves the entire city of Hialeah, and then some. After the
hurricane took the roof off their shelter, they were forced to move
current and new residents into hotels. Safe Space South is in a
similar situation, operating without a permanent facility. The lack
of funding is a problem but other outside factors have worsened the
situation. Rodriguez says that part of what hinders a facility
reopening is that, with about 250,000 total people displaced by the
storm, shelter is scarce in general.
The South
Florida housing boom has worsened matters. “We can’t even buy a
property in good condition, or one that needs to be fixed up,”
because of the “outrageous” price tags on property, Rodriguez said.
“It’s an atrocious problem.”
More than a year
later, both Safe Space South and Women’s Shelter of Hope remain at
least partially unusable, and the organizations have been forced to
relocate some new residents into area hotels and motels. While some
hotels and motels have on occasion waived the charges, the donations
are a temporary fix for the overall shortage.
With such
problems, it’s hard to think about the national statistics: One of
every two women will be battered in their lifetime. Eighty percent
of their children will witness the abuse. Every nine seconds, a
woman is domestically abused. According to Fryer, the shelters have
seen an increase in the need for services this year.
While Miami-Dade
County recorded a slight drop in per capita offenses –
14,474 reported
incidents of domestic violence in 2005 – the state saw a 0.5 percent
increase over 2004, according to the Florida Statistical Analysis
Center of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. The county
still ranks highest in the state for reported domestic violence
offenses.
And with the
holidays around the corner, Fryer expects to see another increase.
During times of stress like the holiday season and hurricanes, the
shelters see an upsurge in those seeking refuge. With the holidays
also comes increased alcohol consumption. Alone, drinking does not
increase the risk of domestic violence, but it does lower the
inhibitions of those already prone to abuse.
Shelter is so
scarce that while the Women’s Shelter’s Rodriguez instructs her
staff never to take victims into their own homes, to protect them
from their abusers, the desire to is almost overwhelming.
Even with the
severity of the shortage, both Fryer and Rodriguez strive to make
clear that no victim is ever turned away. “We call on our
neighbors,” Fryer said, referring to Broward County and even Keys
shelters. “We don’t let victims out on the streets.”
Most recently
Rodriguez was called by airport security to assist a woman who had
been sleeping in the airport with her child to escape her abuser.
“I’m a survivor of domestic violence,” Rodriguez said. “They say
‘spend a weekend with a family member’ but if the abuser knows the
family.…”
Usually, Fryer
and Rodriguez say, the police are the first line of communication
between a victim and the shelters. Rodriguez has known police
officers and firefighters to get victims into hotels for a night and
even pay out-of-pocket to protect someone from an abuser.
“Our South Dade
shelter was severely damaged; they had 23 beds before,” Fryer said.
Fourteen of those were able to be moved to another already
established shelter facility. Fryer says the county is working to
renovate and reopen that shelter.
Down in South
Dade, when the transitional housing shelter is full, they try to
relocate victims to the already taxed Safe Space North, but
inevitably some victims feel uncomfortable being so far away from
their families and friends.
Victims can stay
at Safe Space North and South for up to eight weeks of emergency
shelter; after, they can then be placed in one of the county’s two
“transitional housing” facilities. There, they can stay for up to
one year and, as often occurs, be assisted in finding Section 8
housing on a permanent basis. The transitional housing spots for
Safe Space North number 20 apartments.
Fryer explained
that some women don’t want to leave abusive relationships because
they think their standard of living will be dramatically reduced.
“Usually we get
our referrals from police. They know [the abuser] is going to bond
out in 24 hours,” Fryer said. “There are programs, advocates in the
Miami and Miami Beach Police departments, Jewish women’s groups and
others that refer people here. In my opinion there are not enough
shelters,” Fryer said.
Safe Space North
alone saw 329 new female clients last year, 331 children and six
men. Men are not permitted to stay onsite because the shelter isn’t
big enough to house two wings, so male clients are relocated to
hotels, which the shelter pays for. At one time hotels and motels
were donating a night’s stay to victims to help ease the burden on
shelters through a program called Project Debbie. Those offers have
since dried up, and the shelter’s tab is sometimes $385 per week or
more.
Although the
average stay is about six to eight weeks, says Fryer, those involved
in the immigration process tend to stay longer owing to legal
troubles. “We don’t care about a client’s immigration status,” said
Fryer. But they do provide a host of referrals to services including
legal, health, psychological, job placement, rehab and detox
programs. One of the biggest components to the shelter is on-site
counseling.
Safe Space North
once had an in-house clinic provided by Jackson Memorial Hospital
that not only tended to the various injuries resulting from domestic
violence, but also offered other medical services, including
immunizations and even diagnosing cancers. The shelter has managed
to retain a triage nurse from the same hospital who can assess the
severity of conditions and refer the patient to appropriate care,
but the full-service clinic is dearly missed, Fryer says.
Some county
officials have not turned a blind eye to the problem. Money has been
trickling in from the County Commission and the Domestic Violence
Oversight Board. Of the $1.5 million in grant money the Women’s
Shelter of Hope has requested from various sources in recent months,
the County Commission has granted a total of about $270,000 to be
distributed over the next year. Most recently the shelter applied
for a $100,000 grant from Baylor University in Texas, and was
awarded $60,000 of it. Rodriguez credits her District 6 Commissioner
Rebeca Sosa with providing an immense amount of support and “lots of
money.” Nonetheless, the shelter system is forced to wait for the
big grants to come in from the county and state.
Sosa says the
whole county needs as much help as possible. “We don’t have enough
people to work with the children,” she said. Although there are
programs, facilities and support in place, Sosa is working to create
a program called the Blue Ribbon Committee to train staff in police
departments and other areas to work directly with children. Sosa is
also pushing to get a new shelter open in her district.
“I am working on
identifying a place that we can buy or an old building that can be
fixed up – a hotel or motel to become a big shelter in my district,”
Sosa said. “There was already an allocation of funds. I would like
to see it happen in 2007.”
“They’re all
trying to find solutions because that’s their job,” Rodriguez said.
“Sometimes [commissioners] only like to work in their district, but
Mayor [Carlos] Alvarez and our commissioner have worked a lot to
help find a solution.”
But the support
must go on. Rodriguez is currently “tearing apart” her office to
make room for much-needed pro-bono family court and immigration
legal help.
And this coming
year the shelter will host a few charity events, one its annual
Memory Dinner on May 19, the other a Masquerade Ball themed
symbolically after the two faces created by the mask from The
Phantom of the Opera. Rodriguez is proud to say she just got a
calendar to place the events on. “Before they were just written on a
piece of paper,” she said.
Comments? E-mail
angie@miamisunpost.com.
Domestic
Violence Crimes include:
Murder,
Manslaughter, Forcible Rape, Forcible Sodomy, Forcible Fondling,
Aggravated Assault, Aggravated Stalking (1996-present), Simple
Assault, Simple Stalking, Threat/Intimidation & Arson (1992-1995).
Source: The Florida Statistical Analysis Center of the
Florida Department of Law Enforcement
For help, call the 24-Hour Domestic Violence Hotline at
305-349-5888 or the state’s domestic violence hotline at
1-800-500-1119. |