|
 |
|
They arrived wearing yellow
T-shirts, but did they receive what they were
promised? Photo by Harry Emilio Gottlieb |
Just when I thought I was out,
they pulled me back in. They being the multitudes
concerned with the political knife fight between Mercy
Hospital/Related Group and Everyone Else.
For those of you just tuning in, on April 26, three of
five Miami city commissioners voted to approve a zoning
change allowing Related Group to potentially build
something evil and untoward (condos or a nuclear power
plant, one of those), no doubt leading to the end of the
world as we know it. We all saw it coming and, well, it
did. Flash and cash won the day. At least, I figured,
the hospital would get something out of it to make
much-needed renovations.
In other corners of this lonely metropolis, the fickle
minds of the populace turned to such topics as whether
or not to hang Dolphins Coach Cam Cameron from the
nearest construction crane (for picking a nice little
wide receiver over the hottest young quarterback in the
universe). “We don’t need a Camarón as coach,” an
outraged friend complained to me. “We need a Tiburón!”
(For non-Spanish speakers, it’s a matter of shrimps and
sharks.)
But in the Coconut Grove blog world, time stood still.
Reactions ranged from apoplectic to despicable. One of
my favorites made a hilarious picture of the three ayes
(Joe Sanchez, Angel Gonzalez and Michelle Spence-Jones)
as bobblehead dolls controlled by Mayor Manny Diaz. In
other places, people posted racist comments that made me
want to slap them.
One persistent rumor was that the dozens of black folk
who sat in the commission chambers in yellow T-shirts
supporting the zoning change had been paid $100 to be
there. This happens sometimes in Miami, at the county
and in various municipalities. Old and/or poor people
develop a sudden interest in topics hitherto unknown to
them, board a bus, don a T-shirt and Bam! The magic of
the political process happens. It’s sad, but
unfortunately, not illegal.
Then I got an e-mail. The e-mail came from someone in
the Vizcayan camp, a group of volunteers that advises
and advocates for the Vizcaya Museum & Gardens, a
national historic treasure that was doomed by this
particular decision. The e-mail described a curious
phone call an unidentified man made to the organization,
complaining that he was supposed to be paid his $100 for
supporting the condo project and he hadn’t received it.
I called this man, a Liberty City resident who asked not
to be identified. He told me that he’d been in Coconut
Grove on April 25, visiting his girlfriend, when he was
approached on the street by a woman with a clipboard.
She asked him whether he wanted to make $100. As he was
not opposed to the idea, he accepted the offer to appear
at City Hall the following morning, sign a list and don
the requisite yellow T-shirt.
A couple of hours of light dozing through a meeting
later, this man left City Hall. But he was dissatisfied
because he hadn’t gotten his money. He said a few people
got the cash that day, but the rest were not paid. They
were unhappy. “There were a few people like myself,” he
related. “But did you see the people there? 95 percent
of them were crack heads. Half of them were asleep.”
This man called someone over at the Vizcayan group, he
said, because he’d been told that the vote was all about
saving Mercy Hospital and Vizcaya from a developer.
He wasn’t the only one confused about who owed what and
why. Commissioner Marc Sarnoff, who had vehemently
opposed the project, told me that his office received a
phone call from someone asking when they could come by
and pick up their $100. He was flabbergasted by the
irony.
The morning of the fateful meeting, he’d been informed
by a bemused city staffer that “the entire room is full
of African Americans and they’ve been paid $100.” As
Sarnoff looked out from the dais on a sea of
disinterested faces, he considered for a moment asking,
“How many of you out there were paid $100 to be here?”
Then he thought better of it. “I thought it would have
cheapened the process,” he said, regretfully. “But I
would have had 50, 60 hands.”
Later, after three fellow commissioners had helpfully
cheapened the process for him, a police officer told him
at a meeting that a rumor was floating around the West
Grove that Sarnoff was the man to see about getting the
promised payments. Ron Nelson, a former Coconut Grove
Village Council member who recently resigned to join
Sarnoff’s staff, called him and said, “There’s a riot
occurring in the West Grove that people are not getting
their $100 and they think it’s from your office.”
Sarnoff dispatched Nelson and another staff liaison,
Yvonne McDonald, to handle the crisis. They drove to the
residence of one Henry Riley, a well-known entity in the
West Grove living on Percival Avenue.
Riley, McDonald told me, was one of the T-shirt
organizers. There was “quite a crowd” assembled at his
residence, complaining about not getting their money.
She told him to tell the mob that Sarnoff had nothing to
do with the $100 deal. He obliged.
That little political corruption faux pas apparently
jogged the real money people to get with the program. My
T-shirt-wearing source had called the Vizcayans around 2
p.m. Friday afternoon, but by about 7 p.m., he and a
number of others were standing outside Lottie Person’s
house, waiting to be paid.
Person, he said, had coordinated some of the support.
Person is a member of the Coconut Grove Village Council,
representing the West Grove, or as some would have it,
Village West. My disgruntled yes-man waited around until
a car pulled up. “Rosario Kennedy was the lady [who]
brought all the money,” he said. “I got her phone number
right here. She pulled up in, I think, a gray Honda. She
had a little case full of money.”
Cash was, he said, dispensed. But apparently, not
everyone was paid. Saturday afternoon, McDonald went to
City Hall, where she found at the door a woman she
recognized from the West Grove. The woman was trying to
get in to “see the man” about her $100. McDonald advised
her that Sarnoff was not the money man. “It was sad,”
she recalled. “You could tell she wanted to go get
high.”
Tuesday evening, I sat in on a portion of the Village
Council meeting. Sarnoff gave an impassioned speech
about the proposal he sent to the mayor to veto the
zoning change. Failing a complete ban, Sarnoff wants the
mayor to ask the commission to impose a high “green
building” standard, require public parking and a baywalk
be provided, tree planting and other civic goodies that,
taken together, would probably make the project too
expensive for Related Group to build anyway.
Sarnoff also lamented the method in which the developer
and the hospital procured fake support from poor people
and a couple of homeowners’ associations. “How cheaply
and freely we sell ourselves,” he said. “We as a society
and as Miamians have to come to grips with who we are.
Don’t sell yourself for $50, $100 or $3 million if
you’re a homeowners’ association.”
Sarnoff said that he and his staff had heard other
stories as late as Tuesday about people not getting paid
or only receiving $50 or $75, not the promised $100. As
Sarnoff spoke, Lottie Person sat uncomfortably in her
council seat. When he left the room, she asked to speak.
Person emphasized that she was a big supporter of
Sarnoff and mumbled something about hoping she’d be
allowed to be on his campaign team in the next election.
“But there was some issue that came up and I supported
it,” she admitted. “Because, you know, Village West is a
poor community and I’m for jobs.” (One argument the
developer made was that the condo construction would
provide jobs.)
Then she said this: “It’s important that the people in
Village West know Marc Sarnoff didn’t have anything to
do with what happened.”
Translation: People, stop asking him for your $100.
Kennedy, a registered lobbyist for the Related Group
project, was visibly handling (along with Person) the
yellow T-shirt people at commission hearings. The
Daily Business Review wrote a recent story that said
she was also apparently lobbying Commissioner Michelle
Spence-Jones on the subject, a big no-no should anyone
actually enforce the law prohibiting such contact.
Neither Person nor Kennedy returned phone messages
seeking comment by press time. Neither did Related Group
executives I called and e-mailed. I hope they write
letters, though. Paying for support in this manner is
not illegal, as far as I know, but it is sleazy.
What does it say about the city commissioners who were
obviously aware of this manipulation? What does it say
about the project that Related Group and/or Mercy
Hospital would even consider it necessary? And lastly,
what does it say about the people they hire to do the
deed when it is handled in such a sloppy and transparent
manner?
I’ll let Sarnoff answer that. “Sometimes when you
overreach, you overreach in every way,” he said of
Related’s efforts to push its project. “That’s when you
reach in the cookie jar and you break the jar.”
One last thought, for the over-privileged Grovites who
grumbled about poor black people being used by a
developer: This is exactly why the entire Grove needs to
come together to support the impoverished neighborhoods.
Ignore Village West at your peril.